Beamer I think you're getting a couple of arguments confused here or at least you are globbing them together.
One is about kb+m superiority and why it would upset the balance in a console game. I agree with you there.
The other is about using keyboard and mouse (or hell just a PC hooked to a TV) in the living room. Something you always fight so passionately about for some reason and all anyone's ever said is it's not as big a hassle as you make it sound.
No need to jump all over Jivaro about kb+m in console games, that's not what he was arguing.