An 89% Editor's Choice award for Crysis 2, and an 84% and "id still makes some of the finest corridors in PC gaming" for Rage.
Crysis 2 felt like a solid 80-something game, and Rage wasn't over rated too badly imo. It was a decent 70 in my book (which given id's pedigree is disappointing in itself but in a vacuum the game was decent), which goes back to my original point that PC Gamer has become a bit more discerning with their Editor's Choice awards it seems. It seems especially so since the Dragon Age 2 review; maybe they got called on it by so many people that they had a bit of a wake-up call.
“The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.” - Mahatma Gandhi