You are giving Hellbinder too much credit. You assume he's actually a sane person of sorts.
Not all, or even most, Christians talk and think like Hellbinder, but he is not the only one by long shot. If he were, he would be easily ignored. Alas, it's not just a case of one crazy person; I've been to churches where the preachers there make Hellbinder seem logical and rational with their insane ranting.
I have the highest respect for decent Christians; I know a lot of them myself. Hellbinder and his ilk are not in that category. They are dangerous.
“The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.” - Mahatma Gandhi