The reviewer not only didn't know who made the previous games, but he claims the new Max is way better hero than the first two games. Iirc, the only games Rockstar was making back then was GTA. Oh also, mentions what big fans everyone is around the office. It's all completely contradictory.
Now does it sound like he really even played the first two games? Not to mention, has Rockstar EVER released a game with story as compelling as MP or MP2?