The Advocate wrote on May 11, 2011, 12:45: I can see the connection. Both objects are overhyped*, underperforming* cult objects that should have long ago faded away and made room for better products.
*Full Disclosure: I fucking HATE the Beatles. For about a decade of my childhood, that is all my Dad would listen to. Burned out on them entirely and I can not view them objectively.
Pretty much this. I never got The Beatles at all. I even recently went back and listened to a lot of their stuff to see what I just didn't get and never found it. It's just generic 60s rock with uninspired lyrics and their later stuff is just nonsensical (likely cause they were all stoned when it was written). My opinion's obviously in the minority though.
As Sho said, Pitchford actually has a cogent point that he's just explaining poorly which is a problem he often has it seems. He's not saying Duke has the type of following The Beatles have, just that he's still talked about today because even when people are making fun of it, many of those conversations also have fond remembrances of how great Duke3D was at the time and that does help sell it. A lot of the people who are going to pick up DNF are going to do so because they want to see if it can rekindle what they loved about the past ones.