That's gotta be one of the best researched "historical accuracy" reviews of a video game Ive ever seen anywhere, the author even lists references. Great read!
It was a really interesting review to read. I learned some history doing it. On the other hand the guy played about 10 turns of the campaign and 5 skirmishes. It felt really weird for him to be presenting his opinions on portions of the game that he obviously didn't spend more than an hour attempting. So it was a great read, but I'm not sure it was a useful review or a good precedent.