Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
User Settings
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed

Warren Spector - Why Metacritic Should Be Irrelevant.
The fact is, few of us will ever approach that Platonic ideal of art, commerce and critical acclaim achieved in equal measures. And that means each of us must decide for ourselves how to define success. For me, that means achieving a kind of self-satisfaction - knowing my team accomplished the goals we set as effectively as we could, given circumstances. For me, that means living up to the priorities captured in a personal mission statement. For me, that means doing well enough, commercially, that someone will step up and fund my next game.

Gamer Horizon - Star Wars and EA is a Good Thing.
When I think of EA I don’t see “the worst company in America.” I see the publisher that gave me some of my favorite experiences this generation like Skate, Mass Effect 2 and to a lesser extent, Mass Effect 3, Dead Space, and Mirror’s Edge. I see them in the business of entertainment, and like all in the business, they have some misses minor and major. If Kathleen Kennedy is okay with the Star Wars brand in their hands, then so am I. I haven’t been this excited about the future of Star Wars in over a decade.

Post Comment
Enter the details of the comment you'd like to post in the boxes below and click the button at the bottom of the form.

43. Re: Op Ed May 17, 2013, 11:40 EternityInBlack
I actually want to shed more light on this because I don't think people understand to what end Metacritic is actually being used in the industry. It's true that people use it post-release to gauge the success of the game, but a lot of it is also used prior to funding development.

I've spoken to several of my colleagues who work in the industry and they've been employed in several companies before, in both publisher and developer roles. The gist of what I got is that a lot of things at the negotiating table are done with Metacritic in mind. Let me give you an example.

Let's say you're a publisher and you sit down with a developer. They're unproven, or they have games that have had lower Metacritic scores. The publisher asks, "So you have a good vertical slice of a game... we know what it is capable of being, but what do you have for us that will ensure that we'll get a quality product?" The developer comes and says, "We guarantee a Metacritic score of 80. If it doesn't, we'll waive cuts on profit."

In that example the developer, to prove themselves, have to throw out a Metacritic number to be funded. Now I'm sure that a lot of other negotiations are more complex than what I presented, but the basic gist of it is this: Metacritic scores, as useless as it is for some, is used as a bargaining chip for a lot of things in the industry.

My opinion? It's totally bogus. Scores can be inflated or deflated depending on who is reviewing the game. Some outlets might receive the game and some outlets might not. Metacritic does selectively choose outlets for inclusion on the site, but one PC game might have 50 reviewers, and another 90 reviewers for another, maybe more high profile game.

This puts to light, of course, the irony that we post review scores on our site. There are just people who do go to sites because of scores. I wish we could remove it, but in the end it's the nature of the beast. As a compromise, we've set 1-10 as our ratings with no decimals and, in addition, we've explained what that means on our site.

Ratings are always going to be a tricky thing... but unless we come up with a better barometer reading for popularity outside of sales, executives are going to use Metacritic as THE defacto standard in judging the potential and quality of a product.
Avatar 57719
XBL: EternityInBlack
PSN: EternityInBlack
Steam: EternityInBlack
Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
      ;)   ;)   :(   :(   :o   :o   %)   %)   :)   :)   :|   :|   ;P   ;P   X|   X|   :D   :D   More
Login Email   Password Remember Me
If you have a signature set up, it will be automatically appended to your comment.
If you don't already have a Blue's News user account, you can sign up here.
Forgotten your password? Click here.
          Email me when this topic is updated.

Special Codes

  • b[bold text]b
  • i[italic text]i
  • u[underline text]u
  • -[strikethrough text]-
  • c[code text]c
  • +[bullet point]+
  • q[quote text (indented)]q
  • [quote="Author"]quote text (indented)[/quote]
  • [url=Link]text[/url]
  • r{red text}r
  • g{green text}g
  • b{blue text}b
  • m{maroon text}m
  • s{secret text (shows in the background colour)}s

Forum Rules

  1. Disagree all you want but attacks of a personal nature will not be tolerated.
  2. Ethnic slurs and homophobic language will not be tolerated.
  3. Do not post spam, links to warez sites, or instructions on how to obtain pirated software.
  4. Abusing the forums in any manner that could be construed as 'griefing' will not be tolerated.


Blue's News logo